4 comments

• 

  Randy Charles Morin

  2 years ago

  Swarmcast was open source and not proprietary. Swarmcast was not developed in Toronto, but was purchased by Opencola, which never did anything significant with it other than sink it. I believe you are also wrong about Justin re-purchasing the IP.
  reply
• 

  Paul Kelly

  2 years ago

  Opencola devoted a lot of resources to the development of swarmcast. Lots of developers worked on it for many months.
  reply
• 

  mrG

  2 years ago

  as one of those OC swarmcast developers, I can also tell you that Swarmcast was only superficially like bittorrent; for one thing, Swarmcast worked ;) but the real innovation still unmatched was the insightfull use of the Foreward Error Correction -- this is the same method used by cellphone networks and this technology (not invented by Justin, just adapted to filesharing by him) is the "free software" core of the otherwise proprietary swarmcast technology (FEC is still on sourceforge somewhere).
  
  Another SC filetrading innovation in the use of hash-trees allowed swarmcast to be used for real-time live streaming broadcasts; this facility is still largely untapped by the media although I believe it was employed by CityTV's FashionTelevision to distribute their archive broadcasts (long long before YouTube and Google would make streaming media mainstream.
  
  So why did bittorrent skyrocket after the death of napster but SC didn't? My theory is two factors, not the least of which was that Justin just didn't go to the right parties, but also the SC implementation was in Java, and java for a windows desktop was not a popular opinion in those days. Had the desktop client been in C++ or even Python like BT, it may have fared better. As for being opensource, remember, in those days neither of the top browsers was 'free' as in free speech, and the swarcast client was just as free as in free beer.
  
  Oh, one other thought: we intentionally made SC difficult for bootleggers to spread illegal copies; to distribute content, you had to own that content; that probably shot SC in the foot relative to BT more than all the other reasons combined.
  
  But don't shed any tears for OC Swarmcast: upon the collapse of OC, Justin regained the ownership of his wares and founded onionnetworks.com, and they are still very much in business still profitably serving the industrial sector that OC would not consider ;)
  reply
• 

  Mathew Ingram

  2 years ago

  Thanks for that historical perspective, Gary.
  reply