Mathew's comments - Latest Comments in McGuinness: ISPs should fix my business

Re: McGuinness: ISPs should fix my business

Gerd Leonhard — Wed, 13 Feb 2008 14:26:51 -0000

Greetings everyone, I just posted my reply to Paul's speech here: http://www.mediafuturist.com/2008/02/welcome-to...
I guess I just couldn't resist - there is just too much bizarre stuff in this speech. Cheers, Gerd Leonhard (Music & Media Futurist, Author of Music2.0)

"Let me ask you this, Paul: do you really advocate web sites, communities and networks scanned and censored, emails read and screened, Instant Messenger conversations monitored, Skype calls supervised, USB sticks DRM’ed, hard-drives sealed, flash memory cards locked, rootkits and software locks on our computers, a read-only web, the end of remixes, and the implementation of an online police state that without a doubt will only bring us new censorship and the demise of fair use and free speech while the un-paid and unlicensed trading of music will soar to new heights in 100s of new ways that we don’t even know about today..."

Re: McGuinness: ISPs should fix my business

mathewi — Fri, 01 Feb 2008 21:18:02 -0000

Thanks for the comment, Chris. I was with you right up to the part
where you said we need to force ISPs and tech companies to create
technology to stop downloading. I really don't think that's going to
accomplish anything, except to make a lot more people spend even more
time trying to get around those technologies. Why not ask ISPs to
offer accounts that have a voluntary charge tacked on that will go to
compensate artists?

Re: McGuinness: ISPs should fix my business

Chris Alpiar — Fri, 01 Feb 2008 21:13:34 -0000

What Paul McGuinness really is saying is a voice for all of the artists out there, not a greedy money grubber.

As a professional composer and performer who isnt in the top 1% of success and MTV rock monsters I am THRILLED that someone with clout is making these issues be vocalized. Its not the U2s and the Mettalicas that suffer, its the indie artists, score composers, and working musicians that are being destroyed by the wide open not even attempted at regulating illegal downloading of all kinds of media, including music, song & albums, films, art, scores, etc

Thank you Mr. McGuinness for bothering to talk about the issues that are a nuisance to you but are life threatening to thousands of us!

I also was a dot com boom programmer and I was an original pre-IPO member of InfoSpace and I understand the tech side very much. I will say that what happened is a natural evolution of technology and human nature. Clicking on files and getting that intellectual property of another person was SO EASY and since it was just digital it felt to have to real value. But we all listened to those MP3s and watched those quicktime movies. And we LOVED the fact that we could stuff a 200 gig firewire drive to the brim with all the music we ever wanted to listen to and not pay a dime. If you didnt do it on some level you are probably either a priest or someone without internet

And so Mr McGuinness is saying lets not blame individuals and human nature, but something MUST be done about this and soon before we lose many facets of modern art and culture to the destabilizing and deflation of its economy.

Its no joke and its not like yea yea whatever, its like EMERGENCY *DINGDINGDING* EMERGENCY. Right now the AFM (musicians union) performance fund (which is the fun for retirement and emergency funding for professional musicians) is about to die, because it is based on CD sales. There are *countless* programs similar to this that are dead or dying quickly because of illegal downloads.

Certainly non-"mainstream pop" art forms like non-synthesizer orchestral film music, among many others are going to become extinct and then fade away completely the farther this goes without being checked.

There absolutely needs to be legislation that forces ISPs and tech companies to create technology to stop non-paid-for illegal downloading of music, film and art. This would be relatively very easy to create. All it needs is ubiquitous agreement and cooperation from all sources that host and transmit data.

Without it our world is going to become a shallow grey world without culture and professional art. That is a place I don't want to live in.

Re: McGuinness: ISPs should fix my business

mathewi — Wed, 30 Jan 2008 02:50:02 -0000

:-)

Re: McGuinness: ISPs should fix my business

MarkDykeman — Wed, 30 Jan 2008 00:14:41 -0000

I'm playing the world's tiniest violin for McGuinness, can you hear it?